Silicosis And Related Conditions

Our plain-English summary of Silicosis And Related Conditions, by L.U. Gardner (1937).

The study

• Author: L.U. Gardner
• Published: Journal Of Industrial Hygiene And Toxicology 19(3):111-125, March (1937)
• Type of article: Journal article
• Our copy: from Johns-Manville's own medical library, J-M no. 002920. The article is still under copyright, so we describe it here rather than post it.

In plain English

This 1937 lecture by L.U. Gardner of the Saranac Laboratory addressed silicosis, which the author defined as a chronic lung disease resulting from prolonged inhalation of fine silica particles. It mainly reviewed earlier reports and laboratory work on nodule formation, complications, tuberculosis and diagnosis. Saranac experiments with common silicates had shown no sign of fibrosis within a year in an uninfected host. The author said it awaited experiment whether silicates are entirely inert when infection is present, and noted that certain silicates seemed to promote the growth of tubercle bacilli. Silicotic guinea pigs infected with a weakened tuberculosis strain almost invariably developed progressive tuberculosis; inhaling non-silica dusts did not produce this effect. Asbestos was described as the exception among silicates. It produced fibrous tissue in human and animal lungs, and its fibers were not cleared and became coated. The scarring began around the smallest airways, was often under the pleura, and was more severe with infection. The author suggested that fiber structure may matter more than chemistry, and noted that a comparison of eight asbestos types was under way.

We wrote this plain-English summary from the full article with the help of AI, and a second AI model checked each sentence against the article. It is not the authors' wording; the abstract and the article are their own account.

What the study did and found

• Design: Published lecture reviewing silicosis and related dust diseases, drawing on other researchers' reports and on Saranac Laboratory autopsy and animal work
• Who was studied: No single study population. The lecture discussed silicotic workers described in other reports (for example South African miners and Barre granite cutters), 167 autopsy specimens received at the Saranac Laboratory from people with a history of industrial exposure to various dusts, and laboratory animals (guinea pigs, rabbits, white mice, cats).
• Exposure: Mainly free crystalline silica dust, with silicosis defined as resulting from prolonged inhalation of fine particulate silica. Also discussed were amorphous silica, combined silicates, other inorganic dusts, and asbestos, described as a group of fibrous hydrated magnesium silicates belonging to the amphibole and serpentine groups.
• Main results:
  • In Saranac experiments in an uninfected host, a number of common silicates showed no suggestion of fibrosis or progressive reaction within a period of 1 year.
  • The author noted that certain silicates also seemed to have the power of promoting the growth of tubercle bacilli.
  • Asbestos was described as the exception among silicates: when inhaled, it produced fibrous tissue in the lungs of humans and animals.
  • Inhaled asbestos fibers were not removed from the lungs by phagocytes and the lymphatic system.
  • Asbestos fibers became surrounded by an iron-containing coating, forming structures the article names (in partly garbled text) as asbestosis bodies. They excited a fibrosis beginning about the terminal bronchioles, often with a subpleural distribution.
  • In the presence of infection, the reaction to asbestos dust was much more severe than that caused by the dust alone.
  • Tubercle bacilli that produced only limited lesions in normal animals caused progressive tuberculosis in silicotic animals, but not in animals treated with non-siliceous dusts. This was reported for guinea pigs infected with an attenuated human-type strain, and for rabbits, white mice and cats infected with human organisms.
  • In silicotic guinea pigs, infection with the attenuated strain almost invariably caused progressive tuberculosis; inhaling non-siliceous dusts did not produce this effect.
  • In 167 Saranac Laboratory autopsy specimens, tuberculosis incidence was reported separately for cases with nodulation and for cases with only nonspecific perilymphatic dust changes. The printed percentages are damaged by scanning and cannot be reliably read.
• The authors' conclusion: The author suggested that the physical structure of asbestos fibers may be more important than their chemical composition in causing injury. The author also concluded that infection is the major cause of disability in silicosis.
• Limitations the authors state:
  • The author stated that it remained to be shown how far the harmful properties of asbestos are due to its silica content.
  • The author stated that silicates might not prove entirely inert in the presence of infection, and that this hypothesis awaited experiment.
  • The comparative study of eight types of asbestos was still in progress at the time of the lecture.

Topics

Medical terms in this study, explained in our Lexicon: Silicosis, Saranac Laboratory, Silicate, Fibrosis, Pleura.

Browse return to medical research.