Silicosis And A Few Of The Other Pneumoconioses: Observations On Certain Aspects Of The Problem, With Emphasis On The Role Of The Radiologist

Our plain-English summary of Silicosis And A Few Of The Other Pneumoconioses: Observations On Certain Aspects Of The Problem, With Emphasis On The Role Of The Radiologist, by E.P. Pendergrass (1958).

The study

• Author: E.P. Pendergrass
• Published: American Journal Of Roentgenology 80(1):1-41, July (1958)
• Type of article: Journal article
• Our copy: from Johns-Manville's own medical library, J-M no. 001624. The article is still under copyright, so we describe it here rather than post it.

In plain English

This article is the text of the 1957 Caldwell Lecture. In it the author, a radiologist, described observations on reading chest x-rays for silicosis and other dust-related lung diseases. It drew on the author's own experience and on other researchers' work, and it was not a new study of a defined group. Most of the author's experience came from one industry with essentially pure quartz dust, followed for twenty-two years. On asbestosis, the author reported that x-ray findings appeared first in the lower half of the chest and that early disease was hard to detect. In some patients the x-rays were essentially normal while lung biopsies showed thickened air-sac walls and asbestos bodies. The author had biopsy studies on a few mill and textile workers and one pipe coverer. The author also described a proved, well-advanced case of asbestosis in a man who covered pipes with asbestos insulation. The author said they had not personally studied lung cancer in asbestosis, and noted that other authors held opposing views on that link. The author concluded that radiologists play a major role in diagnosing pneumoconiosis.

We wrote this plain-English summary from the full article with the help of AI, and a second AI model checked each sentence against the article. It is not the authors' wording; the abstract and the article are their own account.

What the study did and found

• Design: Named lecture (Caldwell Lecture, 1957) combining a narrative review of other researchers' work with the author's own clinical and radiological experience; not an original study with defined subjects
• Who was studied: The author's experience: mainly workers in a single industry with essentially pure quartz dust, followed over twenty-two years, plus individual cases and some collective studies of coal miners, pottery, iron, foundry and asbestos workers. For asbestosis, lung biopsy studies on a few mill and textile laborers and on one person who covered pipes with asbestos insulation. No numbers or dates are given for the asbestos workers.
• Exposure: Silica (essentially pure quartz), coal dust, and asbestos. Fiber types are not named. Asbestos jobs mentioned are mill work, textile work and covering pipes with asbestos insulation (dust from sawing and fitting the coverings).
• Main results:
  • In asbestosis, the author reported that x-ray findings were seen first in the lower half of the chest.
  • The author reported that in some patients x-ray findings were essentially within normal limits, while lung biopsies showed thickening of the walls of the alveolar sacs and respiratory bronchioles, and asbestos bodies. The author stated that this experience did not agree with Cartier's view that clinically important asbestosis is always detected first by x-ray.
  • The author examined a well-advanced, proved case of asbestosis in a self-employed man whose job was covering pipes with asbestos. As a result, the author found it difficult to say how much and what kind of exposure is needed to produce asbestosis.
  • The author reported that, for the most part, x-ray signs of asbestosis were not recognizable until the fibrosis had reached the visceral pleura (the lining on the lung surface).
  • On asbestosis and lung cancer, the author had not personally studied any cases. The author cited other authors' opposing views on whether the two are causally related; those findings are not this lecture's own.
  • Among silicotic patients referred to thoracic surgeons with a presumptive diagnosis of lung cancer, the author's x-ray diagnosis had been silicosis with infection in every instance except 2. One of those 2 exceptions proved to be a carcinoma. The total number of patients is not given.
• The authors' conclusion: The author concluded that pneumoconiosis remains a health hazard and that the radiologist plays a major role in diagnosing it in living people and in estimating disability. The author proposed that a national committee on pneumoconiosis protection and/or control be formed.
• Limitations the authors state:
  • The author had not had lung biopsies on asbestos mine workers, only a few on mill and textile laborers and one pipe coverer.
  • The x-rays the author had seen of asbestos-related lung cancer cases were not serial studies, but films of advanced lesions.
  • The author's experience was largely limited to one industry with essentially pure quartz dust.

Topics

Medical terms in this study, explained in our Lexicon: Silicosis, Chest X-Ray, Asbestos Bodies, Biopsy, Insulator, Lung Cancer, Pneumoconiosis.

Browse return to medical research.