No fee unless we recover compensation for your family Text size 833-4-ASBESTOS (833-427-2378) Free Case Review

Study

Asbestos-Related Lung Cancer May Be Deadlier Than Other Lung Cancers

A French study suggests lung cancer linked to work with asbestos may carry a worse outlook, though the difference was not certain after accounting for other factors.

Asbestos, once prized for its resistance to heat and fire, still causes disease today. It causes mesothelioma, a rare cancer of the lining of the lungs or abdomen, and, more often, lung cancer. A 2022 review describes asbestos exposure as the most important cause of deaths from on-the-job lung cancer.

A 2023 study in the journal Lung Cancer looked at whether lung cancer patients who had been exposed to asbestos at work survive as long as other lung cancer patients.

What the Study Found

While tobacco smoking remains the main cause of lung cancer, researchers note that asbestos exposure is the most important occupational risk factor for it.

Asbestos exposure is the most important occupational risk factor for lung cancer.

The study was done at the Léon Bérard cancer center in Lyon, France. Since 2014, the center has sent every patient newly diagnosed with lung cancer a questionnaire about past work. When a doctor suspected a work exposure, the patient was seen in an occupational cancer clinic to judge whether the cancer was work-related.

The researchers followed 702 patients diagnosed from 2014 to 2019. Of these, 180 had been exposed to asbestos at work.

  • Patients whose lung cancer was judged moderately or highly attributable to work with asbestos had a higher risk of dying during follow-up: about 32% higher than other patients, before adjusting for other factors.
  • After adjusting for age, smoking, cancer stage, spread to the brain and tumor type, the difference shrank to about 21% and was no longer statistically significant.

What the study can and can't show

The authors concluded that survival in patients exposed to asbestos at work "may be decreased" and called for larger studies. This was one cancer center, and after adjustment the difference could have been due to chance. The study does not prove that asbestos-related lung cancer is more aggressive. It does show that these patients did no better, and possibly worse, than others.

How asbestos leads to lung cancer

Asbestos causes cancer, and researchers are still learning exactly how. A 2020 review describes several processes when fibers lodge in the body:

  • Long-lasting inflammation
  • Formation of reactive oxygen molecules (free radicals), both from the fibers themselves and from immune cells that try to swallow them
  • Damage to DNA
  • Changes in how genes are switched on and off (epigenetic changes), which are not yet fully understood

It is estimated that asbestos exposure causes six times more lung cancer than mesothelioma.

Beyond Statistics: The Human Cost of Asbestos Exposure

Think of a retired shipyard worker diagnosed with lung cancer decades after breathing asbestos dust on the job. Besides the illness, he may face mounting medical bills and the work of proving where, and to what, he was exposed so long ago.

Asbestos lung cancer and the problem of late diagnosis

Although the link between asbestos and lung cancer is well established, asbestos-related cancers have proven difficult to diagnose early and treat successfully. Most asbestos-related lung cancers are diagnosed at a late stage.

Asbestos-related diseases usually appear decades after exposure. By then, a patient may not remember every workplace or product, which can make it harder to show who is responsible. Work records, union records and coworkers often help fill the gaps.

Early Detection: Screening and Talking With Your Doctor

There is no single test that finds every lung cancer early. The screening test shown to reduce lung cancer deaths is a yearly low-dose CT scan, studied mainly in older heavy smokers. A chest X-ray on its own is not an effective lung cancer screening test.

Who should consider lung cancer screening

A 2022 review suggested low-dose CT screening is reasonable for workers aged 50 or older with at least five years of asbestos exposure (or less, if the exposure was intense) who also smoked at least 10 pack-years, or who have asbestos-related lung scarring, other chronic lung disease, a family history of lung cancer, a past cancer, or exposure to other workplace lung carcinogens. A 2019 study in Libby, Montana, where most people screened had been exposed to asbestos through the environment or their household, found most of the lung cancers at an early stage.

Screening has downsides, including false alarms and radiation, so the decision belongs to you and your doctor. Tell your doctor about any asbestos exposure, at work or at home, so it is in your medical record and can be weighed.

Common warning signs include:

  • A cough that doesn't go away
  • Shortness of breath
  • Chest or shoulder pain
  • Coughing up blood
  • Unexplained weight loss or deep fatigue
  • Fluid around the lung (pleural effusion)

These symptoms have many causes. If you have them and a history of asbestos exposure, see your doctor promptly.

Treatment depends on overall health, cancer stage and the type of cancer cells. It can involve:

  • Surgery: When the cancer is found early, removing it offers the best chance for a cure. Options include lobectomy (removing a lung lobe) or wedge resection (removing a smaller portion).
  • Radiation therapy: Targeted radiation can shrink tumors or ease symptoms, often with other treatments.
  • Chemotherapy: Drugs that attack cancer cells throughout the body, often combined with other treatments.
  • Immunotherapy: Treatments that help the immune system fight cancer, an option for some patients.
  • Palliative care: Care focused on managing symptoms and quality of life, at any stage.
  • Clinical trials: Studies of new treatments that may be available to some patients.

No single plan fits everyone. Talk with your doctor about the benefits and risks of each option.

Asbestos lung cancer claims are different from mesothelioma claims. Many asbestos trusts pay lung cancer claims, but they usually require medical evidence linking the cancer to asbestos, such as asbestosis or pleural plaques on both sides of the chest, plus qualifying exposure. A lawyer who handles asbestos lung cancer claims can check which trusts and companies may be responsible and what evidence is needed.

When you look for a lawyer, ask about:

  • Experience: How many asbestos lung cancer cases has the firm handled?
  • Communication: Who will you be dealing with, and how often will you hear from them?
  • Who does the work: Will the lawyer you meet be the one handling your case?

Deadlines apply to these claims and vary by state, so it helps to get advice soon after a diagnosis.

Asbestos still causes lung cancer and other diseases years after its heyday. Studies like this one point to the value of telling your doctor about exposure, considering screening when you qualify, and getting legal advice early.

Our take

What this means if you have, or may have, an asbestos claim

This study doesn't change who can bring a claim, and its survival finding was not certain. What it does underline is that asbestos lung cancer is often found late. If you worked with asbestos or lived with someone who did, tell your doctor and ask whether you qualify for low-dose CT screening. A lung cancer claim usually depends on medical proof linking the cancer to asbestos, so keep your scans, reports and work records. Our asbestos lung cancer page explains what trusts and courts look for.

Read something that sounds familiar? Free case review. No records or product names needed, and no fee unless we recover compensation for your family.

Call 833-4-ASBESTOS Request a review
Sources

This post is news and commentary, provided for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.